Dad’s Favourite: Cheese and Onion Pie

Finished pie and leftover cheese straws

This is Dad’s favourite; I remember having it as a special meal every Easter holiday in the caravan, with mushy peas or baked peas - it only comes out on special occasions now though! This is my Gran’s recipe that I’ve adapted by adding more cheese, I use a really strong cheddar, and the mustard brings out the flavour of it even more, if you’re not such a fan of this flavour you can use a milder cheese, but I think that kind of defeats the object of a cheese and onion pie…

Pastry coming together

Ingredients:

8oz plain flour

2oz lard/Trex (vegetarian alternative)

2oz butter/marg

large pinch salt and pepper

1.5tsp mustard powder

4oz grated extra mature cheddar

8tbsp cold water

3 medium onions

6oz grated extra mature cheddar, plus extra for the top of the pie

3 eggs

Pastry ready to chill

1tsp Dijon mustard

large pinch salt and pepper

1 beaten egg to seal and glaze

Oven at 170oC fan oven/190oC other ovens

7in pie dish, approx 2in deep

Method:

1. First make the pastry by rubbing the lard and marg into the flour and mustard powder until it resembles breadcrumbs. Add the seasoning and cheese and mix well.

Rolled out pastry base

2. Add the water to the bowl slowly and mix with your hand until it comes together to make a soft, but not sticky, pastry. You might not need all of the water, or you might even need more.

3. Tip the pastry out onto a lightly floured surface and bring it together into a smooth pastry. Wrap in clingfilm and chill for at least two hours – the longer the better as it makes the pastry easier to work with.

4. Whilst the pastry is chilling it’s time to make the filling; finely dice the onions, cover with water and boil for 15 minutes, or until soft and translucent.

5. To make the filling add the cheese, eggs, mustard and seasoning to a large bowl and mix.

6. Once the onions are soft, drain them and leave to cool until they’re cold enough to touch so they won’t scramble the eggs, then add to the filling mix. Leave this to one side now until you’ve sorted your pastry.

Lined pastry base

7. Once the pastry is chilled cut it into 2 pieces, of one third and two thirds. Roll out the larger piece until it’s one and a half times larger than your pie tin. Pick up the pastry gently and lay it into the tin. Lift up the sides of the pastry so it falls into the corners and then gently press the pastry into the sides of the tin. Leave the edges over hanging.

8. Pour the pie filling into the pastry base and glaze the edges with beaten egg

9. Roll out the other half of the pastry on a floured surface until it’s 0.5cm thick and gently lay it over the top of the pie. Press the edges together so they seal and then use a sharp knife to cut away the excess pastry (you can use this to make decorations for the top of your pie, or make cheese straws by twisting strands of the pastry, which will take approx. 20 minutes to bake)

Base, filling and lid for construction

10. Crimp the edges of the pie, brush with egg, sprinkle with the extra cheese and cut two small slits in the top of the pie to let the steam escape.

11. Bake in the centre of a preheated oven on a preheated baking tray for 30-40 minutes, or until the pastry is golden brown and the centre of the pie is firm to touch – if the pie browns too quickly turn the oven temperature down slightly and keep cooking until the pie is firm to touch.

Pie ready for the oven!

This pie is tastiest warm or at room temperature, but of course is good straight out of the oven too if you can’t wait! Like I said, we love it with baked beans or mushy peas and some buttery mashed potatoes!

Finished piece of pie!

Happy Baking!

The Baking Ginger xx